with Patricia Rodriguez, Esq. (CA), and
Chad Elrod, Esq. (TX)
6 HR CLE
January 19th, 2013
Los Angeles, CA
(plus $9.95 Shipping & Handling)
Being offered because of popular demand to those unable to travel/attend our January 19, 2013 event in Los Angeles, CA.
Beginning January 1, the Homeowner Bill of Rights will:
- Ban "dual-tracking" (which is when banks pursued foreclosure even though the homeowner was seeking a loan modification)
- Require one contact person per customer
- Increase penalties for robo-signing (which automatically approves foreclosure without anyone reading documents)
- Let homeowners sue for violations
Patricia Rodriguez, Esq.
- Law Offices of Patricia Rodriguez
- Member of the State Bar of California
- Admitted in Central, Northern and Eastern Federal District Courts of California
- Temple University Law School - J.D.
- Temple University Law School - Law Program in Japan
- University of Southern California (USC) - B.S. in Business
- Member of Beverly Hills Bar Association
- Member of Mexican American Bar Association
Ms. Rodriguez obtained her Juris Doctor from Temple University. While there, she participated in their National Trial Team and received exceptional advocacy training from one of the best law school programs in the country. Ms. Rodriguez previously worked for the Camden Public Defenders Office, the Philadelphia Public Defenders Office, the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office and the Los Angeles Public Defenders Office. She currently runs her own boutique law firm in Los Angeles County specializing in Criminal Defense, Foreclosure Defense, and Bankruptcy Law.
California Homeowner Bill of Rights - SB 900
- Procedural History
- Enacted by CA Senate and Assembly on July 2, 2012
- Signed into law by Governor on July 12, 2012
- Effective Date: January 1, 2013
- Expires: January 1, 2018
- Goals of the California Homeowner Bill of Rights
- Stabilize CA housing economy
- Stop foreclosure abuse by lenders and servicers
- Ensure meaningful foreclosure alternatives for borrowers
- Meeting the Goals
- Expand existing foreclosure protections and add new protections to apply to broadly defined “mortgage servicers”
- Prevent mortgage servicers from proceeding with a foreclosure until certain contact with or notice to the borrower
- Prevent the recordation of a notice of default or notice of sale while a foreclosure prevention alternative is in process
- Require a single point of contact for the borrower once they have requested a foreclosure prevention alternative; and
- Give borrowers the right to sue the mortgage servicer for injunctive relief, actual damages and treble damages, for violation of the Act and the right to recover their attorney’s fees and costs if they prevail
Application of the Law
- First lien Mortgages and Deeds of Trust
- Secured by owner-occupied residential property
- Containing no more than four dwelling units
- Large Lenders
- Most of the provisions of the Act only apply to lenders that foreclose on more than 175 residential properties per year.
- Some provisions, including dual tracking, apply to smaller lenders, as well
- Entity Borrowers
- Investment Property
- Borrowers in default who are already in bankruptcy
- Borrowers who have already surrendered their property to lender
- Borrowers who have contracted with someone or an entity whose primary business is advising people on how to extend their foreclosure and avoid their contractual obligations under the loan
- Mortgage Servicer Defined
- A person or entity who directly services a loan, or who is responsible for interacting with the borrower, managing the loan account on a daily basis either as the current owner of the promissory note or as the current owner’s authorized agent, or subservicing agent to a master servicer by contract.
- “Mortgage Servicer” does not include the trustee or the trustee’s authorized agent acting under a power of sale in a deed of trust
- Prevent lenders from contracting with separate entities to manage and service the loans to avoid application of the current laws
- Dual Tracking
- The Act seeks to prevent a lender from proceeding with a foreclosure, while at the same time negotiating with a delinquent residential borrower on a loan modification
- If Borrower submits a complete application for modification, the Mortgage Servicer may not record Notice of Default or Notice of Sale until loan modification process has been completed and the time for an appeal of any adverse decision has passed
- NOD can be recorded:
- If borrower doesn’t accept offer within 14 days
- If borrower doesn’t appeal denial within 30 days
- If borrower accepts the offer but defaults
- Changes to Loan Modification Process
- Mortgage servicer must provide a written acknowledgement of receipt within five days of the receipt of the document(s) or completed application
- Written acknowledgment of receipt to the borrower must include a description of the loan modification process, its timeframes and any deadlines, any expiration dates for documents submitted, and specify any deficiencies in the application
- Written response if the lender denies the application. This written notice must include the specific reasons for the denial and the deadline for the borrower to appeal the denial (30 days).
- Mortgage servicer is not obligated to evaluate applications from borrowers who have already been evaluated or afforded a fair opportunity to be evaluated for a first lien loan modification prior to January 1, 2013, unless there has been a material change in the borrower’s financial circumstances
- Single Point of Contact Established
- Single point of contact throughout the loan modification process and with at least one direct method to reach the point of contact.
- The mortgage servicer must ensure that the single point of contact has the knowledge, responsibility and authority to:
- Communicate to the borrower the process by which the borrower may apply for available foreclosure prevention alternatives;
- Coordinate receipt of all necessary documents and notifying the borrower of any missing documents;
- Timely, adequately and accurately inform the borrower of the current status of the foreclosure prevention alternative;
- Ensure the borrower is considered for all of the foreclosure prevention options offered by the mortgage servicer; and
- Have access to persons with the power to stop foreclosure proceedings
- Single point of contact can be a team of personnel, each of whom is knowledgeable about borrower’s current situation
- Does not apply to small lenders
- Robo-Signing Eliminated
- Recorded Documents
- Any declaration, notice of default, notice of sale, assignment of a deed of trust, or substitution of trustee recorded in a foreclosure or filed in a court must be accurate and complete and supported by reliable evidence.
- Before filing or recording, the mortgage servicer shall have reviewed competent and reliable evidence that substantiates the borrower’s default and the mortgage servicer’s right to foreclose
- Civil penalties of $7,500 for repeated violations
- No entity shall initiate the foreclosure process or record a notice of default unless and until it is the holder of the beneficial interest under the mortgage or deed of trust, the original or substituted trustee under the deed of trust, or the designated agent of the holder of the beneficial interest.
- No liability for good faith error by trustees resulting from information provided by beneficiary regarding nature and amount of default
- New Notice Requirements
- After Notice of Default Recorded
- Within 5 days of the recording of a notice of default, the mortgage servicer that offers foreclosure prevention alternatives must send a written notice to the borrower informing the borrower of foreclosure prevention alternative
- Does not apply to any borrowers who have already exhausted the loan modification process described above in Civil Code section 2924.6.
- Postponed Trustee Sale Date
- Postponement of at least 10 business days require written notice to the borrower of the new sale date and time within five business days of the date of the postponement.
- Failure to comply does not invalidate an otherwise valid trustee’s sale
- No Application Fees or Late Fees
- Prohibits mortgage servicers from charging borrowers application fees for a first lien loan modification or other foreclosure prevention alternative.
- Forbids a mortgage servicer from charging borrowers late fees under the loan for the period during which the loan modification is under consideration, while a borrower has filed an appeal of the denial of a loan modification, or the borrower is making timely modification payments.
- Right to Sue Mortgage Servicers
- Borrowers can sue mortgage servicers for injunctive relief before the trustee’s deed upon sale has recorded, or if it has already recorded, to sue for actual economic damages, if the mortgage servicer has not corrected any “material” violation before the trustee’s deed upon sale recorded.
- If a court finds that the violation was intentional, reckless or willful, the court can award the borrower the greater of treble (triple) damages or $50,000.
- A violation of the Act is also deemed to be a violation of the licensing laws if committed by a person licensed as a consumer or commercial finance lender or broker, a residential mortgage lender or servicer, or a licensed real estate broker or salesman.
- Court may award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to borrower as the prevailing party.
- Lenders defense: Compliance
Homeowner Bill of Rights Questionnaire
- Has the property been sold at trustee’s sale?
- Has a Trustee’s Deed Upon Sale been recorded?
- Have you already surrendered the property to the lender?
- Is the subject property an investment property?
- Is the subject property your primary residence?
- Is the default on your first lien mortgage?
- Is the loan/deed in your name or in a trust/corp?
- Are you currently in bankruptcy
- Has the BK been closed or dismissed?
- Has there been a relief from stay?
- Have you contracted with someone or an entity whose primary business is advising people on how to extend their foreclosure and avoid their contractual obligations under the loan?
- Who is the current lender?
- If not original lender, were you notified in writing of the assignment of your loan?
- Who is the servicer?
- Are you currently in the modification review process?
- When was the application submitted?
- Were you charged an application fee?
- Are you being charged late fees?
- Have you received a decision of the application?
- Who is your contact at the servicer?
- Have you previously applied for a loan modification with this lender?
- Were you given a reason for the denial?
- Is there a material change in your financial circumstances since your previous application? If so, what is the change?
- Has a Notice of Default been recorded?
- Has a Notice of Sale been recorded?